2/23/2013

Why are we paying so much for education system?




There was an article being circulated recently on why employers here preferred foreign graduates or foreign talents rather than local graduates. To put into perspective, the local graduates are from three branded universities that ranked pretty high in all the fictitious ranking systems that you can think of. And the foreign graduates are those locals that cannot get a place in our local prestigious universities and went overseas to second or third rate universities. And the foreign talents that came to take over the places of local graduates are mostly from third world universities that are not even listed among the top universities in the world. And to make matter worst, and more sickening, many of these foreign talents actually got a piece of paper from some degree mills or bought from a back lane without going through universities.

And we claim to have some of the best universities in the world, lectured or tutored by the best academics, and great exchanges with foreign graduates here and in overseas exchange programmes, but somehow still found lacking and not up to the mark.  What is going on?

The Govt is paying billions to attract the best academics from around the world, game the ranking systems to stay among the top universities. There are also many joint campuses with reputable foreign universities. For the money spent, what is the Govt trying to achieve? To produce a Newton or an Einstein, or to rank high in university rankings or to produce graduates that employers shunned?

Does the Govt need to spend that kind of money and other than the latter two objectives, the possibility of producing a Nobel Prize winner is near to zero. Even if there is one, is it worth the money spent? A genius is not produced by having high international rankings or buying famed lecturers or professors. Such talents are inborn and come once in several life times. They are not nurtured. Any good university and a good learning environment and culture should be able to produce them. Newton discovered gravity by sitting under an apple tree. And better still, the irony of it all, if you want a Steve Jobs or a Bill Gates, you can’t find them in good universities.

Why are we spending billions to fatten so many foreign lecturers and professors for? For sure they would not be able to produce the genius that we want and neither would they be able to produce the Nobel laureates if the input, the quality of students, is not up to speck. Are the money worth spent or can be put to better use instead of gaming the ranking system?

26 comments:

Anonymous said...

Seah Chiang Nee's Saturday column

"INDIA may soon put a little international dimension into the growing rift over immigration between S'poreans and their govt.

It has complained that recent laws in S'pore – aimed at placating S'poreans – were imposing restrictions on Indian professionals who intend to work in the city.

This, it says, is a violation of a bilateral free trade pact, the service portion of which grants special preferential treatment to Indian workers.

The 2 countries signed the pact, called Comprehensive Econo­mic Partnership Agreement (CECA), in 2005.

India is unhappy with the changes in S'pore’s employment pass law which it says is tantamount to impe­ding special preferential treatment for Indians.

The pact has opened the doors to many of the 200,000 Indian nationals who take up jobs as middle-level managers, executives and technicians; positions that the locals are losing out on.

News that their govt had granted the right to India to send its professionals en masse here under a free trade pact has shocked S'­po­reans.

People are already furious with the govt over the rapid intake of foreigners."

http://thestar.com.my/news/story.asp?file=/2013/2/23/focus/12747874&sec

Anonymous said...

Does the Singaporeans feel betrayed by their Government?

Will there be protest about the issue?

Anonymous said...

Wither Singapore?

Anonymous said...

India so lawa. Our goverment so so so .... I donno wat to say lah.
PAP kena klengtong by the Indians or is it the Sinkies kena klengtong by the PAP.

Anonymous said...

If I die, it's my business.
And PAP government does not owe me a living.

Why should I vote PAP?
And pay Millionaire Ministers millions in salary to tell me it's my job to look after myself?

Pay a million dollar salary to a Millionaire Minister who turns around and tells me it is not his job to help me.

Am I daft or what?
Is this the country I want my children and grandchildren to inherit?

Anonymous said...

9.54 unfortunately you are in the 40% minority as 60% like it that way

jjgg said...

Rb..CECA comes under the purview of MFA n MTI.n agreement was signed probably on the instructions of the Emeritus..calling them dumb will only insult the stupid....so..we have the same bunch negotiating DTAs...so where have we benefitted from these? Apart from allowing ministers n lackeys to go on their taxpayers' holidays? Hehe

Ⓜatilah $ingapura⚠️ said...

"Education" is one of the biggest rorts in the world. Nowadays you can get "qualifications" for just about anything. It is tied into the Unions, the government, immigration policy etc.

Here in Australia, if you ant to be a cleaner you need to have "qualifications", and pay (or someone else pays) for a "training course". Over the last few decades there has been an explosion in training courses.

I'm not bashing the NEED to acquire skills and keep updating those skills. I'm bashing the system which is funded by taxpayers for really lousy outcomes.

For e.g. here in Oz: One particular undergrad course at one particular university: 22 years of class contact with students who pay around 10k per year. Teachers/ lecturers on tenure get ~90k per annum. Plus holidays. Een if you take into account staff meetings, exam grading...22 weeks a year "real work" for 90k, 130k if you're senior PhD level.

All funded by taxpayer. You talk about scam? Nothing beats a well-crafted government scam. Everyone is SO WELL PAID, that no one rocks the boat.

Don't worry. Same shit will happen in Singapore. Just wait.

In the meantime, if you are a working motherfucker, you have to eat shit 48-50 weeks of the year, less public holidays and special leave -- most people for a much lower rate than 90k for 22 weeks "work".

Angry much?

Anonymous said...

One should keep an eye on student to teacher/lecturer ratio. The hype about
have lower ratio benefits is over hyped.
It can increase the burden un necessary

Anonymous said...

Education system these days are a reflection of ugly elite system. The benefits are overrated and should be bought down to basic. A lot of things can be self study or home study. All these professionals are nothing but robbers in a white suit and they get by cos the law system favours them.

Anonymous said...

6.35pm please lar, education is important and uni teach you the basic. I look at the nus three years business degree and the modules they offered are basic modules for young people to have a foundation. The rest is to learn on the job plus additional courses as one goes almond.

If u think not important, u dare let non uni doctor to operate on you or not? Instead of doing a proper surgical operation to remove whatever, he may just cut your balls off for fun since he knows nothing and only want to have fun

Anonymous said...

6.35 pm knowledge is real lar in many fields,

Anonymous said...

I agree with RB that sinkies are paying too much for education. Even though my kids have scholarship, I still need to top up their bank account for daily maintenance, books, overseas trips etc etc and one degree even under my situation is 40,000 each multiply by four so 160,000. Those without scholarship would be worst.

We should view education as an investment for the country and not expenses like defense etc where whatever you paid for a fighter is gone forever mah

What do u think?

Anonymous said...

Our students went through all the best, best lecturers, infrastructure, exchange programmes etc etc, but not good enough when compare to third world third rate universities.

What a fucking joke.

And how much the govt paid for all the foreign lecturers and professors to replace our local professors and lecturers? And the quality housing provided,....

Ⓜatilah $ingapura⚠️ said...

I think you are losing the distinction between education -- the idea of, and education -- the system.

The system sucks, we can mostly agree on that.

EDUCATION is however you essential ticket to a better, if not great life. Without proper education you cannot do shit -- just sit in the corner, drool spit out of the side of your mouth, and use that spit to lubricate your cock as you gleefully stroke yourself all day long, waiting for someone to throw you a food scrap or two.

Anonymous said...

Matilah, you vulgar bastard

Ⓜatilah $ingapura⚠️ said...

Thank you for the compliment. Say 'hi' to your mum for me ;-)

Anonymous said...

Matilah I dream of your wet mouth everyday when I see your post with sexy photo. Can't help it. Hehe

Anonymous said...

Matilah u ought to be operated on as per 6.42pm. Motherfucker knn

Anonymous said...

Ya send our regards to your mom and sister matilar after they have been sexually abused by u over the years

Anonymous said...

Having a clean, presentable business card can go a long way in helping your home business look more professional.

You should treat your business as a job by setting up a time each day for
"work". Give us a call with any questions at
1-951-805-9645.

Feel free to visit my site; best small home business advertising scheme

Anonymous said...

Even if you're not reaching for the phenomenal heights the Huffington Post has achieved--Airiana Huffington started the blog with $1. Go to Wikipedia if you don't understand what they are talking about.
Professional SEO services include trained and experienced people including content writers, SEO copywriters,
 ecommerce and internet marketing experts, social networking experts and more.


Check out my site; disciplesconnections.com
my webpage > internet marketing association of surplus dealers

Anonymous said...

First off I want to say terrific blog! I had a quick question which I'd like to ask if you do not mind. I was interested to know how you center yourself and clear your thoughts before writing. I have had a tough time clearing my thoughts in getting my thoughts out. I do enjoy writing but it just seems like the first 10 to 15 minutes are wasted simply just trying to figure out how to begin. Any recommendations or hints? Many thanks!

Here is my webpage ... http://www.wolfies-den.com

Anonymous said...

Its like you learn my thoughts! You seem to understand so much about this, such as you wrote
the e-book in it or something. I think that you can do
with some % to drive the message home a little bit, but other than that, this is excellent blog. An excellent read. I will certainly be back.

Here is my webpage - crayons

Anonymous said...

The heаding should have the optimum usage of thе necesѕary аlgorithmіc and targeted keyword denѕity and tips foг the Goоgle
products. Тhе best way to incгеase your rankThe improνe goοglе гanking process
involves maгket resеarch using advanceԁ search tools.
If yοu hаvе already got the nеcessaгy temperamеnt tο be among the top search engines
of the globe. How to uѕe the κеyword" Free" at the beginning of
thе text.

Check out my web sіte ... search engine optimization austin

Anonymous said...

paleo diet recipes are designed for this. With this
approach you can still find a lot. No one -- either
inside or outside of Redmond -- is arguing that change isn't desperately and quickly needed, because it is leaner and more nutritious, according to Linus Pauling Institute. No more" suck it up, at this age you just don't lose weight, notes the
Diets in Review. But vegetables and fruits while restricting animal foods.



Feel free to surf to my page; paleo appetizer recipes