Is it that
the other Asean states are not small states but big states or mid size states
and so did not share the same fear as a small state like Singapore? The next
smallest state in Asean must be Brunei, though its physical size is also much
bigger than Singapore. Indonesia, the Philippines, Thailand, Vietnam, Myanmar
and the rest of the Asean states are not small states. This could be one of the
reasons why they are not joining Singapore as the chorus boys and girls to hype
this fear of a disunited Asean.
A corollary
to this point is that these are bigger countries, or at least some, have
aspirations to be regional powers or leaders in the region, leaders of Asean.
How would they take it when a little red dot keeps climbing on top of them to
shout to the world as if Singapore is the leader of Asean? Would they feel
embarrass or feel that Singapore is usurping their roles as the natural leaders
of Asean and thus feel offended. Could this be the reason why they refused to
join in the shouting game as if the one that shouts the loudest is the leader
and let Singapore shout for as loud and as long as it wants, alone, a voice in
the wilderness?
Is Singapore
sensitive to the aspirations of the regional powers, the bigger states in Asean
to let them take the leadership role instead of trying to be the leader, acting
as the leader, trying to call the shot and to set the agenda? Has Singapore
really taken a look at what it is doing and whether the other Asean states are
behind Singapore? Maybe they also share the same concerns of Singapore but just
did not like to be led by Singapore and thus just keep quiet and refuse to say
anything?
Maybe it
would be wiser for Singapore to share and communicate more with the other Asean
states, say its peace behind closed doors and let the bigger boys to front out,
to take the lead and still getting the message across if the intent is to get
the message across like in the NAM. It is good to know one’s own place and not
to be ‘boh tua boh suay’ even among equals technically. The leaders and people
of Asean too have their pride and do not want a little red dot to lead them
around, acting like the top dog of Asean. Got to be sensitive I think.
What do you
think? Would the Asean leaders fall in and allow Singapore to lead them in the
charge in the international stage using Asean as a vehicle?