Harvesting
Korean Peace Dividends
Vietnamese Lessons
for the US and Korean Peninsula
Ever since the
era of peace arrived at the Korean Peninsula in 2018, the world has waited
patiently with abated breath ready to reap and harvest the expectant abundant
windfall of the Korean peace dividends.
Economic growth and trade benefits are the best guarantee for a lasting
and sustainable Korean peace. The
US in fact holds the major key to unlock and unleash unto the
world the tremendous prosperity from the Korean Peninsula.
The 2019
DPRK-USA Vietnam Summit will see US President Donald Trump meeting DPRK
Supreme Leader Kim Jong-un in Hanoi, Vietnam from 27-28 February 2019. This is their 2nd meeting.
The
significance of Vietnam
as the venue for the 2nd Trump-Kim Summit has both symbolic and voluminous
importance regarding President Trump’s indelible place in history for a major watershed
landmark foreign policy achievement within less than 2 years of his
Presidency.
Historically,
Vietnam shares much similarity and familiarity with Korea. From traditional dynastic empires to
occupation and involuntary colonisation by foreign powers and followed by a
long war with the US over whom they had also prevailed.
The Indochina
Peninsula was forcibly colonised by the French in the mid-19th
century after centuries of flourishing imperial dynasties. Japanese occupation came in 1940 following
World War II. After the Japanese defeat
in 1945, Vietnamese leader Ho Chi Minh declared independence and a 9-years war
ensued with the French colonial power that they finally defeated in 1954. The country was divided into a communist North
Vietnam (or Democratic Republic of Vietnam) and South Vietnam supported by the
US. The conflicts (called the “American
War” by the Vietnamese and “Vietnam War” by the American) lasted from
1965-1973, ultimately ended decisively with the North Vietnamese victory in
1975.
Within a period
of just 30 years from 1945-1975, Vietnam had defeated 2 global superpowers
namely, France and the US, in her fight for independence and freedom. Her aspirations for independence and freedom
should be well-understood and appreciated by similar bloody struggles in US
history.
Arguably,
Vietnam is the only country ever to defeat the might of the American military
through sheer perseverance, courage, strategy and political will. And as the US retreated in defeat from
Vietnam in 1975, it also imposed such crippling sanctions and trade embargoes
so as to hinder the legitimate aspirations and efforts of the Vietnamese people
in economic growth and national development.
On 3 Feb 1994,
President Bill Clinton partially lifted the 19-year-old trade embargo on the Socialist
Republic of Vietnam. He also announced
the formal normalization of diplomatic relations between the US and Vietnam on 11 July 1995.
On 23 May 2016,
President Obama officially lifted the historical 50-year US trade embargo on Vietnam
in a major policy shift in global trade. This removed all the long-standing US sanctions
and trade embargoes imposed on Vietnam in 1975 in the aftermath of her defeat in
the Vietnam War.
Quite
obviously, the Vietnamese peace dividends, albeit delayed by 20-50 years are
simply astounding and staggering. US-Vietnam
bilateral trade grew from just over US$200 million in 1994 to more than US$50
billion in 2019. In 2018, Vietnam ranked
as the 17th US trading partner in total trade value
by November 2018 of US$54.3 billion, with US$8.88 billion exports and imports
of US$45.42 billion (a deficit of $36.55 billion).
Like Vietnam,
the Korean Empire was forcibly annexed by Japan in 1910. Koreans were subjected
to a period of brutal suppression and unimaginable atrocities until the
Japanese defeat in 1945. From 1945,
Korea was partitioned at the 38th Parallel with the Communist
“Democratic People’s Republic of Korea” (DPRK) in the North, supported by China
and Russia, and the “Republic of Korea” (ROK) in the South supported by the US
and Western European nations.
In 1950, DPRK
Leader Kim Il-sung launched the Korean War in an attempt to reunify Korea,
meeting fierce and vigorous resistance from the US and Western European
nations supporting ROK. The conflicts
ended in a ceasefire “Armistice Treaty”
in 1953. In 1991, DPRK and ROK were
accepted into the United Nations.
Both the Korean
and Vietnam Wars were fought for the same reasons to secure independence and
freedom, albeit under different political systems. Their respective national leaders refused to
accept the division and partition of their countries by foreign powers.
As for DPRK and ROK, DPRK
Leader Kim Jong Un and South Korea President Moon Jae-In also signed on 19
September 2018 the Pyongyang
Declaration which affirmed their earlier April 2018 Historic
Panmunjeom Declaration. Together, they declared to the world to
abide thoroughly by and faithfully implement the 2 Agreements, essentially
constituting the Korean North-South
Peace Treaty, and to take practical measures to transform the Korean
Peninsula into a land of permanent peace. Before 80 million Korean people
and the whole world, they solemnly renounced war on the Korean
Peninsula to begin an
era of peace.
The Panmunjom
Declaration for Peace, Prosperity and Unification of the Korean Peninsula was
adopted between DPRK Leader Kim Jong-un and ROK President Moon Jae-in on 27 April 2018 during the 2018 Inter-Korean Summit on
the South Korean side of the Peace House in the Joint Security Area.
According to the declaration,
the governments of DPRK and ROK agreed to cooperate on officially ending
the Korean War to begin a new era of peace and sharing commitments in ending divisions
and confrontation by approaching a new era of national reconciliation, peace
and prosperity and improvements to inter-Korean communication and relations.
In a culturally significant
symbolic act, they stood with their spouses on Mount
Paektu, the spiritual
ancestral mountains of the Koreans to pay homage to their common ancestors and
to proclaim that the North-South brothers are no longer estranged and divided,
and to vow “never again” to war with one another, and to develop mutual relations
for national reconciliation and cooperation for real peace and co-prosperity so
as to realise the common aspiration and hope of all Koreans for cultural,
social and eventual political unity.
As
the sun rose that fine autumn day, the dawn of Korean peace had begun. I was then in DPRK for a different reason.
The
Korean North-South Peace treaty ended the Korean War. The 1853 Armistice signed
on 27 July 1953 was designed to "ensure
a complete cessation of hostilities and of all acts of armed force in Korea
until a final peaceful settlement is achieved”. The Agreement implementing
the Panmunjom Declaration in essence and fact represents that “final peace
settlement”. Following the Peace Treaty,
military exercises were cancelled, border posts removed and the number of
border guards substantially reduced, among other confidence building measures
to enhance peace building efforts.
With their terms and
conditions fulfilled, the United Nations Command
(UNC) established by UN
Security Council Resolutions 83 and 84 are therefore rendered obsolete. The dissolution of the UNC also has widespread
implications and consequences for many countries who benefited from the Korean
conflict. These include up to 7 UNC
Bases in Japan, nearly 30,000 US soldiers in ROK as well as other US assets and
resources deployed in the Far East.
In their 1st Singapore Summit last
year on 12 June 2018, US President Trump committed to provide security guarantees to
the DPRK, and DPRK Chairman Kim Jong-Un reaffirmed his firm and
unwavering commitment to
complete denuclearization of the Korean Peninsula.
Even as they
meet in Hanoi, Vietnam for their 2nd meeting, much focus has been on
the DPRK denuclearization process in progress.
The
US has yet to unveil its framework proposal for DPRK security guarantees as
promised. US security guarantees for DPRK is the major key to fully unlock Korean
denuclearization. In the meantime, crippling
trade and economic sanctions on the DPRK should be eased or lifted to turn on
the flow of Korean peace dividends so as to embolden and empower the ongoing
North-South peace process.
As they embarked
on their 2nd meeting in Hanoi, Vietnam, President Trump and DPRK Leader
Kim should be mindful of the advice of President Clinton and President Obama:
“The
history we leave behind is painful and hard. We must not forget it, but we must
not be controlled by it” (President Clinton, 18 Nov 2000).
[… an opportunity to end a] “lingering
vestige of the Cold War (and) to complete what has been a lengthy process of
moving towards normalization with Vietnam” (President Obama, 23
May 2016).
The multiplier
benefits to the global economy from immediate Korean peace dividends would be
even more tremendously enriching when compared to Vietnam. They must begin to be unlocked and turned on now,
today.