China was forced
to intervene in the stock markets following the recent sell down, wiping
trillions of dollars from stocks and with many late entries suffering painful
losses. The first day of intervention was quickly reversed and the rout appeared
to continue to run to the abyss. China went in with more restrictive measures
yesterday and for the moment has temporarily halted the fall and turned around
with the biggest one day gain of 5.8% in the Shanghai stock market.
The measures
introduced include halting trading of 50% of the stocks and forbidding big
shareholders to sell their shares. Investigations are going on to look at
malicious trading that contributed to the plunge in the market. Though the
measures avoided a free fall and more losses, some market analysts as usual
have started to express concerns about state intervention and not allowing
market forces to do the damage.
What are
these market forces? There will be the natural herd instinct, the panic buying
and selling of investors at any sign or news that would affect stock prices.
What is more dangerous is the collusion of big players, big funds, working in
tandem to drive prices up and down at their callings. These are not the innocent
market forces. These are big market manipulators. They operate as a wolf pack
and reap great profits from the innocent small investors.
All the
western modelled stock exchanges that allowed big funds to trade in them are
faced with this risk of wanton manipulations. How can this be classified as
market forces? These are not your normal investors but bandits that used their
muscles to muscle in and out of a market like a bull in a China shop.
The only way
to counter and prevent these big players from destroying a market and the
wealth of small investors is to have a counter force in the form of govt
intervention. It is only fair. Only silly govts and stock exchanges would think
that govt intervention against these big forces is unacceptable and contrary to
the operation of market forces. How can such big players and their
irresponsible modus operandi to reap huge profits at the perils of small
investors be allowed to run freely and unrestrained and be regarded as fair
play, as market forces?
All govts
and stock exchanges must have an instrument and even war chest to counter the
destructive nature of the big players. Otherwise they are just being
irresponsible and unfair to the small investors, like giving a licence to the
big players to go for the kill, with their approval.
The Chinese
intervention in the stock market is the right thing to do to prevent a very
unfair and unlevel playing field. But what is important is also for the
regulators and govt to manage a bubble and not allow a market to go wild. When
a huge bubble is formed recklessly, the result will be a rout when the bubble
is pricked. The Chinese govt must not let irrational exuberance to repeat again
and for the present, how to unwind and deflate this bubble without causing too
much damages. It was stupid to allow the market to run amok in the last few
months and think that it was normal.
The
volatility in the Shanghai stock market is not over yet and would take quite
some time for the market to stabilize at a lower level.