1. SINGAPORE: Russia’s invasion of Ukraine has sparked intense public debate in Southeast Asia. Within the region, there are worries that segments of society have bought into the Kremlin’s
online disinformation campaigns aimed at swaying sentiments on the war and justifying Russia’s invasion....
2. TWO PRO-RUSSIA NARRATIVES
The first narrative involves the Donbas region and the portrayal of Ukrainian authorities as neo-Nazis bent on subjecting Russian-speaking residents to constant military onslaught and genocide.
The second involves the assertion that the United States operates a network of biological weapons laboratories in Ukraine. Both of these debunked narratives, utilised as justifications for the invasion, have been widely propagated by Russia’s official Twitter accounts....
3. Amongst the 1,961 tweets identified from Singapore- and Philippines-based Twitter accounts, 838 of them mentioned the terms "US", "USA", "America" or "American". A substantial majority of these tweets carried anti-American sentiments. Analysts have highlighted how Russia seems to have masterfully curated their narratives to tap on "existing anti-Western messages" that have appeal in Asia, Africa and the Middle East. The goal here is to convert this reservoir of anti-Western sentiment into goodwill and support for Russia....
4. According to the 2022 State of Southeast Survey, a significant minority of Singaporeans and Filipinos - 21 per cent and 31 per cent respectively - expressed no or little confidence that the US would do the "right thing" to contribute to global peace, security and prosperity. ...
Darren Cheong is a research associate with the Regional Strategic and Political Studies Programme at ISEAS-Yusof Ishak Institute. This commentary
first appeared on the Institute's blog, Fulcrum.
The above is quoted from CNA and reads, this is an authoritative and objective analysis of the Ukraine crisis and ... the Russians are trying to write the narrative which is generally false and disinformation. Agree? Or this is the officially approved version of the Ukraine crisis?
In para 1, it says that the region is worried about segments of society being misled by the Russians as believing in the Russian narrative is bad. True? The region means what, Asean or just Singapore? The underlying statement is that the Russian narrative is false. Really?
Para 2, the two Russian narratives, one, Ukrainian authorities used neo Nazi elements to kill Russian speaking Ukrainians and two, Americans operate bioweapon labs in Ukraine, are untruths and have been debunked? Really? Debunked by who? Has the UN conducted any investigation or no investigation?
Para 3 said a 'substantial majority of these tweets carried anti-American sentiments' meaning a substantial number of Singaporeans and Filipinos are anti Americans. Meaning a substantial number of them don't support the Americans involvement in the Ukraine war. And the substantial numbers include those in Asia, Africa and the Middle East, all anti Americans. This is contrarian to the American's claim that the international community is against the Russian invasion of Ukraine.
Para 4, 21% and 31% of Singaporeans and Filipinos have little confidence in US doing the right thing to contribute to global peace, security and prosperity. Is the author implying that this is a minority and the majority have confidence in the Americans doing the right thing? Or maybe, the same percentages have confidence in the Americans while the balance 40-50% is not sure? By not saying how many percent believe in the Americans doing the right thing, is telling only half truth, half the picture. Why not tell the whole truth since the author must have the full statistic?
The article also implies that Singapore's stand against the Russian invasion has the support of Indonesia, the Philippines and Brunei, that in Asean, Singapore is not alone in opposing the invasion.
What do you think? What is the message of the article and what is the truth? Is it objective and impartial analysis or the author is telling his version of the anti Russian narrative?